When Arnold Schwarzenegger delivered his famous “I’ll be back” line in “The Terminator,” his character made good on the threat.

A handful of former Arizona lawmakers are making the same promise this year. But unlike the cyborg assassin, they’ll need voters’ permission to get back into the Capitol.

By our count, five candidates running for the Legislature this year have been elected there before1, and most are attempting comebacks after voters denied them reelection or a move to higher office.

They’ve already endured the campaign trail and come up short. So what makes them want to do it all over again?

We asked this year’s slate of comeback candidates to find out.

David Cook

Throughout his eight years at the Capitol, former Republican Rep. David Cook built a reputation as a conservative willing to buck his own party.

He was the only House Republican to oppose former Gov. Doug Ducey’s flat tax plan, voted against censuring a Democratic lawmaker for hiding Bibles in the House lounge and helped kill state schools chief Tom Horne’s bill to punish schools for not disciplining students enough.

After reaching his House term limits in 2024, Cook challenged one of the Legislature’s most conservative members, Sen. Wendy Rogers, for Legislative District 7’s Senate seat. He lost.

David Cook (R) served in the Arizona House from 2017 to 2024.

The Globe-based cattle rancher attributes the defeat to Rogers securing President Donald Trump’s endorsement and outspending him in the primary. But Cook believes his odds are better now that he’s running to return to the House.

Republican Rep. Walt Blackman is seeking reelection, but the district’s second House seat opened when GOP Rep. David Marshall resigned earlier this year to become Navajo County recorder.

Both Blackman and Marshall are based in Snowflake, a small town on LD7’s far eastern edge. In a sprawling district spanning parts of four counties, Cook argues that clustering lawmakers in one corner has left large swaths of LD7 without adequate representation. Not to mention, there are open questions about whether Rogers lives in the district at all.

“The voters know me,” he said. “If I go back, I’ll be a right hand. I’ll be a chairman. And nothing against anybody else running, but that is a huge step for not only our district, but all of rural Arizona.”

When it became clear Marshall was leaving and opening up a House seat, Cook said his phone "wouldn’t stop ringing.”

To reclaim his old House seat alongside incumbent Blackman, Cook has to defeat challengers Andrew Costanzo and Barby Ingle in the GOP primary. LD7 has more than twice as many registered Republicans as Democrats, so the four-way primary could effectively decide both House seats.

According to Cook, his former colleagues are ready for his return.

“I got a text yesterday from a chairman in the House that I've known for a long time, and they texted me and said, 'I can't wait till you get back here to help bring sanity,’” he said.

Jamescita Peshlakai

Jamescita Peshlakai (D) served in the House from 2013 to 2015 and in the Senate from 2017 to 2021.

While several comeback candidates are returning after electoral defeats, Jamescita Peshlakai is coming back after trading the Capitol for a federal post in Washington.

Peshlakai previously represented a sprawling northern Arizona district covering much of the Navajo Nation, which has since been redistricted as LD6. She served one House term and nearly five years in the Senate before resigning in 2021 for a tribal liaison position in the Biden administration.

For three years, she worked at the Bureau of Reclamation to ensure tribes were consulted on Colorado River policy, until Trump returned to office and Elon Musk DOGE’d the job out of existence.

Anticipating that her federal job was at risk, Peshlakai applied to the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law, where she’s now studying environmental and tribal law. But losing that job — and watching the administration test the limits of power — pushed her to seek her old seat again.

”There was no hesitation. I saw really extreme, and not only unethical but illegal maneuvers that were happening, and I just got really angry,” Peshlakai said. “I just felt like it was a really hostile takeover, and so I had no qualms about running again.”

She’s now challenging current Democratic Rep. Myron Tsosie for LD6’s Senate seat. Tsosie volunteered for Peshlakai’s campaign in 2015, she said, but she’s not happy with his attendance record and his votes with Republicans.

“I don’t feel like that kind of work ethic — and not being as committed as I am to the life and the livelihood of the constituents of the district — is right,” Peshlakai said.

Peshlakai’s comeback bid is an all-Democratic family affair. Her mother, incumbent Rep. Mae Peshlakai, is seeking reelection, while her aunt, Angela Maloney, is running for the open House seat vacated by Tsosie.

Ian Teller, an Indigenous civic advocate, is challenging the family slate for one of the district’s House seats.

Anthony Kern

Former Sen. Anthony Kern has already pulled off one return to the state Capitol. Now, after a failed congressional run, the far-right Trump loyalist wants back in.

Kern first entered the House in 2015, then served three terms before he was ousted by a Democrat in 2020. After the loss, he became deeply involved in election conspiracies and joined Arizona’s slate of fake electors in an effort to overturn the 2020 presidential election results.

But when Kern returned to the Legislature in 2023 as the senator for the newly drawn LD27 in the northwest Phoenix area, he did not dispute the results of the election that put him there.

Anthony Kern (R) served in the House from 2015 to 2021, then in the Senate from 2023 to 2025.

After one Senate term, Kern gave up the seat to run for Congress. He finished fifth in the seven-way Republican primary for CD8, and GOP Sen. Kevin Payne moved over from the House to take Kern's seat.

While the duo previously complimented each other in the press, they’re now publicly disparaging each other for control of the Senate spot.

Kern was the only comeback candidate who did not respond to our interview request. But he addressed his return during a Clean Elections debate that became a solo Q&A after Payne declined to attend.

Kern pushed back on Payne’s claim, which he submitted in the primary election voter guide, that Kern’s running because he “misses being in elected office.”

“He's never asked me why I wanted to come back,” Kern said. “I want to come back because politics has changed over the past 15 years. The country's kind of gotten more polarized, and we have to have strong fighters like our president, President Trump, who previously endorsed me in one of my campaigns four or five years ago.”

Trump isn’t lending Kern his endorsement this time, so Kern is coming up with his own credentials. His campaign sent out a mailer falsely calling Kern a “certified peace officer,” per the Republic.

Kern left a volunteer deputy position in Tombstone in 2019. Before that, the El Mirage Police Department fired him from a code enforcement job after he lost a tablet and lied about paying the department back for it. The episode landed him on the Brady list, which flags law-enforcement personnel with credibility problems that may need to be disclosed in criminal cases.

“It’s like you steal a pencil, you get the death penalty,” Kern said at the Q&A.

Christine Marsh

Christine Marsh (D) served in the Senate from 2021 to 2025.

After former Democratic Sen. Christine Marsh lost her seat to Republican Sen. Carine Werner in 2024, she deleted the campaign-related files from her computer and prepared to move on from politics.

The following year, Marsh also retired from her more than 30-year teaching career. Now, she works as a caregiver for a 92-year-old man who was her running coach when she was a teenager.

Marsh still runs regularly, often to the mountain preserve where her son’s ashes are scattered. He died from an accidental overdose in 2020, and one of Marsh’s major achievements at the Capitol was getting a law passed that legalized fentanyl testing strips.

When she left her LD4 Senate seat, Marsh moved into a smaller home in north-central Phoenix’s LD5, closer to the preserve where her son’s ashes are.

Then, longtime Democratic Sen. Lela Alston announced she would retire after 34 years at the Capitol — and asked Marsh to run for her seat.

“I would walk through fire for that woman,” Marsh said. “She has left very big shoes to fill, and I plan on doing everything in my power to fill them if I make it across the finish line in November.”

Marsh doesn’t face a primary challenger, so she has a strong shot at replacing Alston in the Democratic-leaning district — a welcome change from the last election cycle, when she faced a smear campaign to oust her from the toss-up LD4.

That pressure now shifts to former Democratic Rep. Aaron Lieberman, who is challenging Werner for the LD4 Senate seat.

Aaron Lieberman

In 2021, Lieberman resigned midway through his second House term to run for governor.

The campaign never caught fire — although he ran an ad featuring a literal dumpster fire — and he dropped out after current Gov. Katie Hobbs and former Nogales Mayor Marco Lopez outraised him.

After his failed gubernatorial run, Lieberman founded a company that installs electric vehicle chargers at apartment complexes.

And now, he’s plugging back into politics.

Aaron Lieberman (D) served in the House from 2019 to 2021.

Lieberman said he entered the competitive LD4 Senate race after Marsh moved away and local Democrats asked him to step in. He represented much of the now-redrawn district during his three years in the House, and Lieberman believes that familiarity with voters will help him make a triumphant return.

He is also more optimistic about what he could accomplish this time. Lieberman believes Democrats could win the Senate majority or force a 15-15 tie, creating “an opportunity to kind of move the state to the middle.”

“That was not the case when I was in the Legislature,” he said. “We were frankly just kind of frozen out of the budget process completely, and that was one of the things that so frustrated me about my ability to make an impact back then.”

So, who won?: It looks like the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors and Recorder Justin Heap finally reached an agreement and now both sides are touting their wins, Stephanie Murray reports for the Republic. Heap previously had his 12-point plan approved by the Arizona Supreme Court, which was considered a major defeat for the board, but Heap walked back certain parts in the final stages. Now, both Heap’s office and the board will oversee early ballot tabulations, which Maricopa County Supervisor Steve Gallardo said is because Heap’s staff “has no clue on what they’re doing” and “didn’t want that responsibility.” Supervisor Thomas Galvin called the agreement “an off-ramp from this highway to hell that we have been on.”

A convenient election promo: State Treasurer Kimberly Yee is still relishing her legal win against 12News, which allowed her to withhold detailed transaction information in the state’s school voucher program. Now she’s rubbing it in the face of her rival in the GOP primary, Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Horne, who settled his own lawsuit with 12News and agreed to provide detailed info.

Fontes locks horns with DOJ: Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes is prepared to duke it out with Trump and the U.S. Department of Justice after the DOJ sent a letter threatening state officials to only allow citizens to cast a ballot, which is already illegal, Capitol scribe Howie Fischer reports. Trump is preparing to drop an announcement today about elections and Fontes is prepared to fight in court to ensure federal officials don't meddle in state elections.

FEMA closes door on Globe relief: The Federal Emergency Management Agency denied the City of Globe’s appeal for federal aid after a disastrous flood killed three people and the agency rejected the original request in December, Alexis Cortez and Steven Sarabia report for AZFamily. FEMA officials said the flood, which caused $96 million in damage, was not severe enough for a “major disaster declaration.”

The news business is in a constant state of disaster. We're hoping you're more generous than FEMA.

They fixed the comma: An Arizona firefighter was denied health insurance coverage for his cancer recovery because of a grammar mistake in state law, Fischer reports. The man, who was diagnosed with non-respiratory adenocarcinoma, was not covered because state law lists the presumed conditions for firefighters as “adenocarcinoma or mesothelioma of the respiratory tract.” His insurer claimed the phrase, without a comma before “or”, meant that his condition wasn’t covered. He eventually got coverage, and the law was revised in a state Senate bill to now list each covered condition, rather than a long list in a single sentence.

Republican Congressman Abe Hamadeh has recently been under scrutiny for strange behavior with his staff.

He got his interns to do a weird, glammed up photoshoot.

And reporting revealed he lives and takes vacation with a top aide who’s now managing his reelection campaign.

But on Tuesday, he got roasted by Arizona Twitter for a hilarious error.

In a video he posted, Hamadeh touted his support for the Sunshine Protection Act — a bill that aims to make Daylight Saving Time permanent.

“We need more sunlight here in Washington, D.C. and all across the country,” Hamadeh said. “See, Arizona — we haven’t changed our clocks in forever, so, uh, you know, I’m happy to vote on the piece of legislation.”

Well, that’s true. But in saying that “America should be a little bit more like Arizona,” Hamadeh seems to be confused.

Arizona never observes daylight saving time. The bill would make Arizona a little more like the rest of America.

Plenty of people, like Goodyear Councilman Trey Terry, pointed out the lack of very basic knowledge.

Perhaps Hamadeh should spend less time with his staff on photoshoots and vacations and more time understanding simple facts about Arizona.

1  To keep things simple, this overview skips over former appointed lawmakers such as LD8 Democratic Senate candidate Deborah Nardozzi, who spent about nine months in the House in 2024.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading