Every year that the Agenda has existed, we’ve threatened to put up a paywall.

And for five years straight, we’ve chickened out.

Someone would say “not today — this one’s too good,” and before we knew it, we’d given the whole year away again.

That’s how you publish a newsletter for five years without ever charging most of the people who read it.

So after some post-election reflection, we’re taking the decision out of our own hands: Starting the first week of the legislative session in January, we’re paywalling some stuff.

Getting into the VIP room is easy.

And because we’ve proven we can’t be trusted with a soft rule on this, we’re imposing a hard(ish) rule (with some exceptions).1

  • Mondays are free, and they’ll a contain a look forward: what’s coming this week, what we’re watching and who’s about to have a bad few days.

  • Fridays are free, too. That’s where we put our big stuff, the stories we most want you to pass around.

  • Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday are the daily drip of insider news. Those are for the people who pay to support our work.

But we want to tell you a little about why.

A moment to brag and beg

We do some of the best journalism in Arizona (and have the awards to prove it).2

And we really like working here.3

But to keep our jobs, we have to convince readers to pay for local journalism. (Specifically, this odd style of serious but fun local political journalism that you’ve come to expect from us.)

Many of the testimonials on our website mention that we’re funny. Except the one from Kari Lake’s lawyer, who has no sense of humor at all.

Democrats winning a trifecta in Arizona’s state government is the single most exciting event in our careers as local political journalists. But honestly, we don’t know if the Agenda will survive the next few years to get to cover it.

Put plainly, election seasons are great for business. Nonelection years are rough.

And that sucks, because the real work of governance isn’t happening in campaign years. It happens in the years after, when voters take their eye off of the politicians.

Who pays the bill

Somebody has to pay reporters to keep watch over the politicians. The question is: who?

Most of the local news startups you’ve heard of only survive because they spend a huge chunk of their time chasing grants.

We don’t rely on grants — on purpose.

Grants are a short-term fix for a long-term problem: Newsrooms spend every year or two competing to please the same few funders, then chase the projects that the rich folk think matter instead of the stories their reporters think matter.4

We’re fiercely independent. We refuse to play the “keep the donors happy” game.

We only dance for our subscribers.

But the tradeoff is that our fates are in your hands.

We hear from readers all the time who don’t know if they pay for the Agenda or not — it just shows up in their inbox every morning.

That’s pretty cool. But it’s also a problem.

It means those who support our work don’t get anything special (except access to our new Slack channel, where the cool kids hang) over those who aren’t invested in our success.

In the meantime, everybody else forgets that it costs actual money to do real local journalism that informs the public and holds the politicians accountable.

A paywall fixes both issues.

And it ensures the Agenda keeps landing in your inbox, whether that’s two days per week or five.

If you truly can’t afford a subscription, email us and we’ll give you a free one. We always have, and that’s not changing.

For everyone else: We’re not trying to get rich here (though that would be neat). We’re just trying not to go out of business right when Arizona politics is about to get good.

Ch-ch-ch-changes: Gov. Katie Hobbs’ chief of staff, Chad Campbell, is stepping down at the end of the month, and current co-chief legal officer Kori Lorick is taking his place, the Republic’s Stacey Barchenger reports. Campbell, a former lawmaker turned lobbyist who helped lead the 2020 campaign to legalize recreational marijuana, joined Hobbs’ team in 2023 after a hellish first legislative session. Campbell is returning to his lobbying and strategy firm, Lumen, which he co-founded in 2023. Meanwhile, at the Attorney General’s Office, longtime spokesman Richie Taylor is moving up to the chief of staff role.

Like teaching at your high school: After a resounding loss in his bid for attorney general, outgoing Senate President Warren Petersen is being rewarded with a new gig as chief of staff for Senate Republicans, the Capitol Times’ Jakob Thorington reports. Current Chief of Staff Josh Kredit isn’t sticking around for life in the minority, but incoming Senate Minority Leader John Kavanagh said Petersen is “probably the most powerful person we could have selected” as Republicans prepare for a largely reactive role under Democratic control.

A moderate victory lap: Continuing their post-election media tour, Hobbs and Lt. Gov.-elect John Giles told Fox 10 not to expect a progressive takeover despite Democrats’ overwhelming election victories, and instead, Hobbs insisted her “approach to governing is not going to change” under the new Democratic trifecta. The duo also stopped by the 12News studio, and while Hobbs didn’t discuss a lot of policy plan specifics, she did say she wants to make sure data centers are “paying for themselves.”

The future of vouchers: Superintendent-elect Teresa Leyba Ruiz wants to end the automatic approval of school voucher purchases under $2,000, the Democrat told KJZZ’s Lauren Gilger in an interview. She claims she can bring some oversight to Arizona’s universal Empowerment Scholarship Account program on day one without waiting on the Legislature, though she said she sees “no reason to stop” school choice — so long as private schools face the same accountability as public schools for the use of tax dollars. Her wish list for the new Democratic trifecta also includes a clean renewal of Prop 123 and finally settling the long-running school facilities funding fight.

Cochise, we have a (power) problem: SpaceX’s push into AI data centers now runs through rural Cochise County, where the company wants to build a 747-acre supercomputer campus near the Willcox Playa, per the New York Times. At full build-out, it would draw up to 6 gigawatts — more than twice what every data center in Maricopa County uses combined, and about 24 times more than the summer peak of the local electric co-op that would serve it. SpaceX has promised to foot $3.6 billion in transmission upgrades and forgo using industrial water for cooling, but county officials will have to approve the project.

Nobody home: The GOP-controlled Legislature has been the last line of defense for a slew of abortion restrictions challenged under Prop 139, but that’s about to end once Democrats take over in January, Jeremy Duda reports for Axios. Attorney General Kris Mayes has refused to defend the laws, so GOP legislative leaders Warren Petersen and Steve Montenegro stepped in to fight the lawsuits themselves. Their Democratic successors aren’t expected to pick up the cases, which will leave the restrictions with no defender in court.

ABC15’s Garrett Archer noticed something a bit odd on Thursday night.

❝

“Something is going down at Turning Point Action tonight. A lot of blue checks and badges are gone,” he tweeted.

Friday started off with rumors circulating that the far-right organization, after the candidates it backed with tens of millions of dollars lost spectacularly in the midterm elections, might be forced to declare bankruptcy before the year’s end.

For a moment, it seemed like the whole house of cards was crumbling before our eyes.

But by Friday afternoon, things were back to normal.

If the Turning Point ship truly is sinking, we’ll have to wait a bit longer to find out.

1  Exceptions to the paywall rule include: We’ll tear down the paywall whenever we feel like it. Some stories need to travel, and it’s our wall. And we’ll tear it down whenever an advertiser picks up the tab. We’re bringing in more of them next year, and when one sponsors a midweek edition, everybody reads free that day. Want to be the reason a 10,000-plus political insiders read free on a Wednesday? Email us.

2  One of those awards is for “Best Newsletter,” where we beat out the Yellow Sheet Report, the Capitol’s insider tip sheet, which is behind a hard paywall and costs about 30 times as much as the Agenda. Just to put that $120 annual subscription into perspective.

3  Please, please, please don’t make us go back to one of the dying corporate papers. We just can’t at this point.

4  At least with advertisers, the deal is straightforward: They get eyeballs — and absolutely zero say in what we do.