Partisan groups of all ilks compiled judicial hit lists this election season urging voters to kick to the curb judges who had run afoul of their values.
And voters took heed, ousting Court of Appeals Judge Anni Hill Foster and Maricopa County Superior Court Judges Julie Mata and Michael Rassas from their jobs.
And now the judiciary is fighting back.
All three judges found themselves at a strange intersection of both Republican and Democratic opposition — and their newfound unemployment was actually a bipartisan kumbaya from voters.
But that rare cross-party agreement that these judges were not up to snuff has riled up Arizona’s Supreme Court chief justice, Ann Scott Timmer, as Kiera Riley reports for Capitol Media Services.

We offer a tiny violin for all the judges who weren’t retained this year.
Timmer, who was appointed by Republican Gov. Jan Brewer, says the election results show Arizona’s merit selection and retention system is “broken.”
And she’s now leading an effort to reform Arizona’s judicial retention system and to protect the poor, “defenseless” judges from the uninformed pack of voters who she argues are hopped up on social media and ChatGPT research.
She plans to convene a committee to review what drove the 2026 election results, prepare major policy changes to voters’ ability to oust judges and provide campaign guidance for judges facing retention in 2028, Riley writes.
“Changes have to be made if we want to save the sanctity of our judicial system,” Timmer said after the election. “The people (who) want to control decisions, want to send messages, want to exact retribution, they have the means and the desire to do it ... So, what do we have to do to change that?”
Well, since she asked, we have a thought: How about you respect the will of the voters?
To understand why Timmer’s plan is such an affront to the very spirit of Arizona — and why it should (and probably will) fail — you have to understand Arizona’s fight for statehood.
Back in 1911, when Arizona was attempting to become a state, a populist wave was sweeping the nation and, especially, the West. The movement was largely born out of Midwest farmers who revolted against railroads, banks and other corporations that were squeezing them, but by the time it reached the territory of Arizona, it ran far deeper than that.
Arizona’s particular strain of populism was both a reaction to the corporate indulgence of the Industrial Revolution and the history of territorialism, which left Arizonans ruled by appointees of the president — who were often stooges of the copper companies and railroads that basically ran the state — rather than a governor or judges who the people picked.
And “direct democracy” was the answer.
Newcomers to our state might be surprised to learn that the Arizona Constitution is an incredibly progressive document.
Like other Western states incorporated into the union at the time, we demanded the right of the people to make their own laws (initiatives), the right of the people to veto the laws created by their government (referendum), and the right of the people to oust politicians outside of the election cycle (recall).

Oregon and several other Western states have similar initiative and referendum provisions in their state constitutions. (The Oregonian, January 10, 1911, via the Oregon Archives Division)
But as anyone who took an Arizona civics class in high school probably knows, the real sticking point in ratifying Arizona as a state was our unyielding demand that the people have the right to yeet their judges.
President William Howard Taft didn’t believe Arizonans should have that right, and he vetoed our statehood resolution, specifically because of our provision allowing for the recall of judges.
He called the idea that judges should be subject to the voters’ “momentary gusts of popular passion” a form of “legalized terrorism.”
“The judge is treated as the instrument and servant of a majority of the people and subject to their momentary will,” under a recall system, Taft wrote in his veto letter.
Some of you may know what happened next.
Arizona faked him out, put forward a constitution that stripped that judicial recall provision and then, immediately after becoming a state, added it back in.

For some reason, Arizona’s judicial recall is often depicted as a Gila monster in old cartoons.
(The Washington Post, May 24, 1911, via the National Archives.)
How very Arizona of us.
And how very Taftian of Timmer to ignore that.
These days, most judges are appointed by the governor, rather than elected. And we haven’t had a judicial recall in ages.1
What we do have left from that era is the idea that judges are accountable to the people.
And that comes in the form of retention elections.
The good ole boys in the judicial system already put their hand on the scales of that enough via the Commission on Judicial Performance Review, whose members are all hand-picked by the Supreme Court. The commission didn’t recommend a single judge be ousted this year.
Plus, voters have time and again shown that they really like the ability to fire their judges.
In 1992, voters gave themselves a cheat sheet. Prop 109 created the Commission on Judicial Performance Review, so Arizonans would have report cards on the judges they were voting to keep. It passed with 58% of the vote. Voters wanted more information to wield that power, not less of the power.
In 2012, the legal establishment asked for longer terms, and got laughed out of the room. Prop 115 would have stretched judges’ terms to eight years and handed the governor more say over who gets picked. The State Bar, the judges’ association, the Legislature and Brewer (who also appointed Timmer) all backed it. More than 72% of voters said no.
In 2024, lawmakers tried to end retention elections almost entirely. Prop 137 would have kept judges off the ballot unless they got in trouble, and it would have thrown out that year’s retention votes after the fact. Voters killed it with almost 78% voting no.
Yes, voters sometimes make stupid decisions. (Ahem, Donald Trump.)
No, that doesn’t give our judges the right to take those decisions away from them.
Our democracy and our judicial system will survive the loss of three judges this year. Judges are replaceable. There’s no shortage of qualified lawyers itching to put on the robe.
And let us be the first to say that when Timmer is up for retention in 2028, we hope voters remember that.

Hiring 535 babysitters: Attorney General Kris Mayes wouldn’t mind not having to keep suing the Trump administration. She’s already filed 50 lawsuits, and she told Axios Phoenix’s Zach Buchanan she’s hoping a Democratic-controlled House and Senate will do the job for her and block the president’s worst policies. Meanwhile, Mayes is also tangling with former Republican U.S. Senate candidate and fake elector Jim Lamon, who went before the Arizona Court of Appeals yesterday to argue Mayes’ prosecution of “fake electors” is politically motivated, KJZZ’s Wayne Schutsky writes. Lamon says Mayes ran in 2022 on a pledge to prosecute him and the other Republicans who signed documents falsely claiming that Donald Trump beat Joe Biden in Arizona’s 2020 presidential election. A lower court dismissed the case Mayes brought against the fake electors because prosecutors didn’t provide the text of the Electoral Count Act of 1887 to the grand jury.
Crunching the numbers: The post-election data analysis is well underway. The Republic’s Stephanie Murray is parsing voter data and chatting with political insiders about who didn’t vote in the midterms. Statewide turnout was the lowest for a midterm in a decade, and the likely culprits for Republican losses are Republican voters who stayed home in red areas like Legislative Districts 14 and 29 (the home district of outgoing Republican Speaker Steve Montenegro), in part thanks to a lack of high-profile presidential and Senate races.
Throwing shade like a pro: ASU President Michael Crow didn’t hesitate to call out Vice President JD Vance for acting like he actually had any power. Crow was referring to a press conference last month when Vance hyped the Trump administration’s crackdown on supposed visa fraud among international students at several universities, including ASU, Alyssa Brown reports for the State Press. (Separately, a federal court in Massachusetts struck down the administration’s four-year cap on student visas this week.)
“The vice president’s not a policymaker; he’s the vice president waiting to replace the president,” Crow said. “We deal with the policymakers, the policy implementers, and we think that they’re throwing the baby out with the bathwater here.”
Who’d a thunk it?: After a half-century of trying to free Arizona’s judicial system from political influences, a report from a progressive legal group says the Commission on Appellate Court Appointments is still driven by party politics, Morgan Fischer writes for the New Times. It turns out, when a Republican is governor, picks for the bench skew toward business leaders and corporate lawyers. When a Democrat is in charge, picks are more likely to be progressive advocates or educators.

Hoping for the thick envelope: Arizona officials submitted their application to be the home of NASA’s U.S. Space Academy. Gov. Katie Hobbs is pitching the Trump administration on putting the academy near the astronomy hub in Flagstaff or the tech hub in Mesa. Other states are also in the running for the academy, which could open as soon as 2028. Let’s see if they have as swanky a website as Hobbs and Co. put together.

If Democratic U.S. Sen. Mark Kelly ever becomes president, let’s hope he’s as much a stickler for getting the facts right as he was in this interview with Politico.
The poor reporter couldn’t get through the intro she’d written up without Kelly interrupting her so much it ground the interview to a halt.
Dasha Burns: We are here in San Diego, which is also my hometown...
Mark Kelly: And a great Navy town.
Dasha Burns: A great Navy town where you just walked in a Veterans Day parade with the USS Midway. You flew 39 combat missions in the Gulf War, many of them off the Midway.
Mark Kelly: All of them...
Dasha Burns: All of them off the Midway.
Mark Kelly: ...off of the Midway.
Dasha Burns: You said 199...
Mark Kelly: No, I said 299...
Dasha Burns: Two hundred ninety-nine...
Mark Kelly: ...carrier landings.
Dasha Burns: ...carrier landings.
Mark Kelly: So I have 375 carrier landings on like six or seven different ships, but 299 of them are on the Midway.
Thanks for clearing that up, Mark.
1 Though we will say, the last recall we could find really cuts against our argument: The Ku Klux Klan successfully backed a recall of a Pinal County Superior Court judge in 1924.


